Green Bay review, and around the horn…
Friday, November 14th, 2008Tonight has compelled me to finally write a post on this beautiful website, thanks in part to my older brother. He and I have been going back and forth over the Green Bay Packers and New York Jets.
Instantly you know that I am talking about Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers.
After the Jets attempted to lose last night’s game to the New England Patriots, everyone has singled out Brett as the reason why the New York Jets are as good as they are, while saying he’s the reason why the Packers are only 4-5.
That could not be further from the truth. Based on the backstep of Green Bay’s D and the fact Ryan Grant hasn’t broken a huge touchdown run the way he did last year has been a big factor. Let’s also not forget the weaker schedule for the Pack last season due to the poor season they had the year before.
The Jets have a much easier schedule this year, improved their defense and offensive line and they have been relatively healthy all year. They also get to shread the NFC and AFC West divisions - both very weak.
But if we flipped both players, Favre back to Lambeau and Rodgers in New Jersey, what would we have? Well, based on the performances individually we could be seeing different records. I’ve been told Green Bay would be better with Favre and the Jets would be worse with Rodgers. Really? Says who? Don’t you think clubhouse morale would be lower with Favre in it? I’d bet on yes.
But Rodgers has committed 7 less interceptions than Favre. So don’t you think he could have won the close game the Jets lost to Oakland? What about the first New England game? And what if Kurt Warner doesn’t have 6 turnovers in the Arizona game? Did Brett cause those turnovers?
No, just like Rodgers didn’t let the Minnesota offense score the late touchdown last weekend. And how would Favre hold up against Indy or Tennessee? Green Bay faces the best division in the AFC and the most up-and-coming divisions in the NFC, the South. Green Bay does not have the weaker schedule they had last year, as well as the gift of facing floundering teams in the best spots of the season (Faced the Giants and Chargers early, both teams were in a cloud at those times).
We can admit that the quarterback position has been a big difference in New York. I cannot say the same for Green Bay. But Green Bay would not be a better team with their previous quarterback. Rodgers has protected the ball and his team’s defence has not rewarded him for that.
Lets not give too much credit for the guy who only gave another team a heads-up on his former team’s playbook and strategy.
Around the horn
- Barry Melrose was fired by the Tampa Bay Lightning. It was a stupid hire in the first place. He had a nice little gig with ESPN and had the opportunity to get to the Stanley Cup finals with Wayne Gretzky and Luc Robitaille - with the aid of some poor refereeing in the Conference Finals. And this is coming from a guy who can’t stand the Leafs.
The thing that got him fired was not playing 1st overall pick Steve Stamkos. I am not sure why. Tampa needs to play him with the best players to get him ready to become the best. He has the luxury of playing with studs like Martin St. Louis and Vince Lecavalier. Let him work with these guys. The ice time Stamkos has received is embarrassing. As a 1st overall player, he commands more respect than that. The next coach needs to play him a lot and allow him to learn and work through the problems he may have.
- Brian Burke has resigned from Anaheim and looks to potentially be the next GM for the Toronto Maple Losers. Burke is a nice GM, a good GM actually. However, he is very overrated and to think he is the answer to Toronto’s problems is a pipe dream. He is no better than Cliff Fletcher. He lucked into winning a ring with a franchise he did not build. Aside from the title, his record isn’t something to completely brag about. So as Toronto prepares itself to overpay Burke, they will need more than a nice GM to get themselves over the top.
- The Yankees are ready to overpay for C.C. Sabathia. But, they might as well overpay for a guy who’s been near the top for a few years rather than waste money on 1-hit wonders (Jared Wright and Carl Pavano), as well as avoiding age (Randy Johnson and Kevin Brown). They are at least going after a top-flight pitcher rather than a poser (A.J. Burnett). Now they need a first baseman and I doubt they will have the money to get Mark Teixiera.
- If there is a team that needs a rebounder and reliable scorer from the 4 and 5 in the NBA, grab Antonio McDyess. He’s not the beast he was 10 years ago, but who is? Get him (TORONTO! PLEASE!)
- Mike D’Antoni hasn’t learned a thing since moving to New York to coach the Knicks. He still only uses 7-8 players every game. The Knicks will fade.
- So far I have agreed on the MLB awards (Gold Glove does not count), but whoever did not vote Cliff Lee and Roy Halladay 1 and 2 in the Cy Young should never be allowed to vote ever again. Just like the douche bag who voted Tim Lincicum 3rd should never vote again. The twat that voted for Dale Sveum should never vote again. In fact the guys who did not vote for Lou Pinella or Charlie Manuel should never vote again. Not only is it baffling, its insulting that you would be allowed to vote for something so important if you are going to be an imbecile about it.
That’s all for tonight. Enjoy the weekend.