Most criticized QB: Rex Grossman
Thursday, September 20th, 2007Fact: society is not color-blind. We aren’t. Regardless of how open-minded we are or far from racist we may be, we aren’t color-blind.
However, I find the recent comments from Donovan McNabb to be very bitter and inaccurate. The most criticized quarterback in the NFL today happens to be Rex Grossman, who is very white.
McNabb plays in Philadelphia where criticism comes from everyone in and out of the football stadium. Grossman plays in Chicago - one of the biggest cities in the United States.
The second most criticized quarterback, in my opinion, comes from the city that never sleeps: Eli Manning. Not only does he face the tough media and fans, he also has a name to live up to. Makes sense since he plays in a large city.
This is not me trying to prove a point - this is just the way I see things. Maybe you see it different.
But I’m not going to sit here and tell you McNabb does not get criticized. He does. But instead of looking at the situation as him being a black man who’s prone to criticism because of his skin or the way he plays the quarterback position, look at other reasons such as completion percentage or wins/losses. If he wasn’t pathetic the first two weeks we’d be looking at a man who’s led his team to a 2-0 record and we’d be loving him the way we always have.
Oh wait, could we love him so much that we could call him, "overrated"?
Ponder that for a second while I imagine Jeff Garcia in an Eagles uniform as the starter and wonder what could be going on this season.
Ok back to the overrated comment. The one way someone can be considered overrated is when we lift a player’s status above what the player has earned. More than just Rush Limbaugh has believed that notion about McNabb. Therefore, he has been treated well for his play at one time or another.
What also struck me were some of his quotes:
In regards to Peyton Manning and Carson Palmer: "Let me start by saying, I love those guys. But they don’t get criticized as much as we do. They don’t." (1)
- Yes, except they have performed - regardless of the weapons they have and Donovan does not.
In an interview on HBO’s "Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel" to be
broadcast Tuesday, McNabb said black quarterbacks "have to do a little
bit extra" because there are relatively few of them, adding "people
didn’t want us to play this position." (2)
- Well, I want the best quarterback to play the position regardless if he is black, white or another color. With the stakes so high in the NFL, I bet all the coaches want to see the best player at that position as well, regardless of skin color. And, just to clarify things here are a list of other starting black quarterbacks:
Steve McNair - Past his prime, still effective at times
David Garrard - Not that good, but decent start to the season
Vince Young - So far so good, but not quite established just yet
Jason Campbell - Not that good either
Tarvaris Jackson - Even worse
So there will be criticism and its not about skin color.
Just a final question as we get set for Week 3 in a few days: does Bryant Gumbel need to turn some of his interviews into a race issue? This isn’t the first time Gumbel has been around race issues on his programs. Wonder if he thinks we hate his terrible play by play skills because of the color of his skin. Absurd.
I’m not here to say there isn’t a race/color issue in sports because someone probably has a problem, but ultimately sports is all about winning and the majority of people feel that way. McNabb is a good quarterback who didn’t get blindsided during the interview, he just got a little shortsighted.