I’m not an editor. Hell, I’ve barely been a contributor to RSB as of late. Therefore I’ve decided to call myself the “non-editor” and answer some questions people have been asking as of late…
*Is Kurt Warner a Hall of Famer?
- To me, yes. I’ll put the argument this way; if Ben Roethlisberger were to win the Super Bowl most experts believe he is a Hall of Fame quarterback in-waiting. Well, I hate to break this to you all but Big Ben isn’t Kurt Warner when both are at their very best - not even close. So if Kurt’s team wins the Super Bowl wouldn’t he be a Hall of Famer?
Look, 2 Super Bowl rings, 3 NFC titles, 2 League MVP’s and one of the greatest quarterback comebacks we’ve ever seen in recent years helps. What pushes him over the top are the numbers he has put up if you isolate his MVP years plus his other top years. If you take his first 3 seasons in St. Louis and his last 2 years in Arizona the only quarterback that rivals him during his era is Peyton Manning - a first-ballot Hall of Famer.
*Will Michael Vick make it back to the NFL?
- Yes. Teams will be looking at quarterbacks next year and with the build-up of the Wildcat Formation, they could use a guy like Mike Vick who can probably still run and throw a bit.
As his name has been brought up this week I’ve really gotten over the incident, to the point where I look at other NFL players and think they’ve gotten away with more despicable acts. As bad as it was to look at the damage done to these dogs, I’d hate an NFL player more if he beat up his wife. Perhaps it is my “human beings first” mentality, but humans make the world go round. What also doesn’t help the situation is P.E.T.A. sticking their nose into affairs they have no business dictating. The more facetime P.E.T.A. gets, the more I begin to sympathize with Vick - and THAT isn’t right.
*Will a former Super Bowl-winning coach get hired to coach an NFL team this season?
- All arrows point to no. To me this is not right. If you have a struggling team and you have fired your head coach and you DON’T hire a guy who is clearly an upgrade then you shouldn’t be running an organization. I realize hiring a co-ordinator or a no-name is the sexy thing to do thanks to the success of Baltimore or Atlanta, but that plan is not full-proof. There is a failure rate with this model that organizations are ignoring. When you have guys like Mike Shanahan, Jon Gruden, Brian Billick and Bill Cowher without a job there is a problem.
On the flipside, the NFL is preparing for a potential lockout in 2011 and do not want to throw huge cash to these coaches. At the expense of your team’s success you are running a bigger risk saving money on a no-name coach than throwing big cash to a proven winner. You owe it to the team to set them up to succeed in the biggest possible way and stop trying to look deep into the future.
*Is Cleveland the team to beat in the NBA?
- No. But in a couple weeks that answer could change. To me, there are a few teams in the mix and there is no clear-cut favourite. Cleveland lost to the Lakers, who lost to Orlando, who lost to…wait a few weeks on that.
*Is Mark McGwire’s Hall of Fame chance over if his brother writes a book?
- Probably. I only keep the door open because there will be the “Phil Rizzuto appeal” for Big Mac from guys he played with and against. People will talk about how he helped saved Baseball with his monster year.
I have a question that only real sports fans (and real sports bloggers) can truly answer: would the game have died if McGwire was clean and only hit 35 homeruns? Would the game have died if Roger Maris was still the all-time record holder? No. The game would have found it’s way back regardless, and I’d argue that steroids and overinflated offence prolonged the baseball-recession after the strike.
*Is the NHL doing the right thing by suspending players if they opt to skip the All-Star game?
- Not really. What they should be doing is telling the All-Stars to make an appearance but don’t play. Otherwise, forget having an All-Star game and just name an All-Star team at the end of the year without any game. Nobody seems to miss the All-Star game when it is skipped during the Olympics anyway. However, the All-Star game is big revenue for the NHL and they need to count their pennies as they have announced that they will now be deducting 25% off each player’s paycheque because league revenues are down this year. That is not a good sign.
*Who needs the Australian Open title more, Rafael Nadal or Roger Federer?
- I’d say Nadal. He has proven he can win on clay and grass but he has yet to show dominance on the hard court. I think he needs this title more than Federer, who is clearly still a top-flight player who can get it done despite being on the downslide of his career. His downslide is better than everyone’s prime, which is scary.
*What should we hope for as the PGA season progresses?
- Hope that Tiger Woods is healthy, that Phil Mickelson has won some chip-and-dip, no pressure tournaments and that Padraig Harrington is playing good golf because they can now legitimately promote a potential rivalry thanks to Harrington’s recent success in major championships. That would be the kind of build-up that golf hasn’t seen since Lefty buried himself in the 2006 US Open.
*What is the temperature outside?
- Very cold. It is currently -18 celcius, which is 0 in your terms. The heater is in overdrive. Enjoy the warmth!
29 Comments »
Filed under: 1